data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/48851/488514cb0361910b6f52eea8bd283808293524b4" alt="Linux Business Linux Business"
Linux Hits the Road 207
An anonymous reader writes "Vicroads does regular surveys of the roads in Victoria, Australia, to determine where they need to be patched or otherwise repaired. It used to be done in a vehicle travelling at 20 kph: slow, tedious, and hazardous to the traffic around it. Now, thanks to Linux, it's being done at speeds of 80 to 100 kph. The Melbourne Age has the details. Short version: the cost has fallen from $1.2 million Australian to $850,000. Not bad..."
car video guidance (Score:3, Interesting)
Comment removed (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:car video guidance (Score:2)
Re:car video guidance (Score:2)
Re:car video guidance (Score:2)
Are you powering you computer with a bicycle generator right now? That would be better for the environment you know. You'd get more exercise too.
Seriously though, I bet you'd love the winters up here on your bike.
Re:car video guidance (Score:1)
Re:car video guidance (Score:2)
Re:car video guidance (Score:1)
now winning an election would probably be easier, but i'd still like to see if it's possible and reliable. safety isn't really one of my primary concerns.
Re:car video guidance (Score:1)
Re:car video guidance (Score:2)
I saw their latest thing on TV a few years back, the scaled down system consisted of a laptop and a tiny video camera clipped to the rear-view mirror. And the car was going 60 mph. Moore's Law + a decade and a half of s
Re:car video guidance (Score:2)
I've been dreaming of a system like that for a while now. Just remember, lines may be obscured, poorly drawn (adding and removing lanes), unmarked roads.
Also, remember to put proxi
They have this... (Score:2)
Re:car video guidance (Score:2)
So has DARPA... See "Grand Challenge".
*Evil Grin*
Hmm, let's see... I believe the resolution of GPS is about 1 meter. Quite accurate really, just not accurate enough for the road. If your car is one meter off, that would either put it in a ditch at the right side of the road, or directly in the on-comming traffic lane.
You know it's late... (Score:5, Funny)
BFD (Score:5, Funny)
So what. So they saved $36.83US. What's the big deal?
Re:BFD (Score:2)
How many $US a $AU has buying. Up up up. I think the US currency is the one that's in trouble
Re:BFD (Score:2)
I hate to reply to my own posts, but I got to confess, this is a troll.
As much as we Americans pity the rest of the world, this still was a bit over the edge. And the Australians have it particularily bad, so you shouldn't pick on them. Shame on me.
Re:BFD (Score:2)
best line (Score:5, Funny)
hey steve, start booking that flight!!!
Multiple FireWire cameras under Linux? (Score:5, Informative)
(I wrote FireWire camera support for QNX, and looked at the Linux code to see how to do some things. It didn't help much.)
(Windows support for FireWire is painful in a different way. It's incredibly complex, and has far too much kernel code, to allow for DRM. And the Video for Windows retrofit for FireWire is flakey.)
Re:Multiple FireWire cameras under Linux? (Score:2)
Just curious, when was this?
I'm not heavily involved with Linux firewire, but I've been tracking it vaguely, and I understand that they've actually got a proper solution for the hotplug thing that works against 2.5 (and presumably, now, 2.6).
Now, I'm not *using* 2.5 or ne
Re:Multiple FireWire cameras under Linux? (Score:2)
Backport it to 2.4 and I'll be impressed. Until then, for most users, the firewire support is about as useful as tits on a bull.
Re:Multiple FireWire cameras under Linux? (Score:2)
Penguin (Score:3, Funny)
The penguin road patrol
But where will this technology go from here? (Score:5, Interesting)
Perhaps when the sun is low shadows would be cast over potholes that would lead to lower temperatures inside the crater than on the surface of the road. That would make infrared cameras an obvious choice for picking out the cold-bottomed potholes.
Or perhaps a rear vehicle could shine a light at an acute angle to the ground that would turn potholes into shadowy pits for easy detection by a forward vehicle on the other side of the pothole?
So many possibilities. (So many challenges!)
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:4, Funny)
(Car hits pothole - ka-THUNK!!!!)
Computer : Crikey! Didja feel that!?! Stone the flamin' crows, who was the bushwhacker that built this goat-track? Strewth!!
(Computer makes note of position for future reference.)
That way, subtle potholes (eg small depressions in road with no sharp edges) could be picked up fairly well.
And I hold the patent for "a method for use of Australian Slang to accurately measure and describe road defects", so no getting any ideas
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:2)
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:2)
Well, Duh - you don't have to fix the ones you don't run over...
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:2)
Also, it could be that minor damages in untraveled areas could spread.
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:2)
Re: (Score:2)
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:2)
But it's a fact that everyone has a distorted view of people in other places, simply because they don't live there - the only things they *do* see are the extremes, because the norms slip underneath the radar and go unnoticed.
And if you're Australian , and I'm Australian, I'm pretty sure that Australia is not a hoax, but I'll agree with you on the Fosters remark
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:2)
Re:But where will this technology go from here? (Score:2)
Sonar would be good enough, is fast enough, and is very cheap. Sonar modules are readily available and m
Re:A "bumpy" problem. (Score:2)
Like, take one of those depth-finder/fish-finder boxes, and watch for deviation.. Sounds like a good plan. If the road goes higher or lower, log it.
Linux not the answer (Score:5, Interesting)
Re:Linux not the answer (Score:5, Informative)
And Ferguson said it best at the end of the article: "Development using open source software means the developer is totally in charge. You can do what you like, and customise things to your own needs. There are downsides, like the problems I faced with the firewire drivers. But then you'll generally find that you are not alone in this; there will be others to contribute little bits of knowledge until the jigsaw is complete."
So to say that Linux is "incidental" is a little bit of an understatment.
Re:Linux not the answer (Score:2)
Problem is.., Linux isn't doing the video capture and monitoring. Linux is the OS that a custom application is running under.
This is a newspaper article?!? (Score:4, Interesting)
Soeriously now, an nwspaper article that mentions
limitations in the firewire drivers.
I mean the readers are expected to know what drivers, RAM, firewire, is.
They call Linux robust and hint that windows isn't.
There is no catch!!!
Now this is unbelievable!!
This must be a hoax article.
You don't really get stories like this in the newspaper
And you foreigners wonder ... (Score:1)
favorite comment (Score:5, Funny)
the road ahead (what is technically called the pavement)
sweet advert for OSS... (Score:5, Insightful)
And that's where OSS evangelism has to happen... showing that OS is better even with its problems, not that proprietary is worse and OS is perfect. Good for them
I use linux... (Score:5, Insightful)
"My experience with Windows is limited. I have been a Linux user since 1993 and I have considerable experience in programming in that environment," Ferguson said. "In any case, I don't think that I would have undertaken a task like this, where a computer is on the road, using anything but a robust operating system."
I mean, is it *really* that much harder to grab some video in Windows vs Linux? Having never programmed in Windows, perhaps someone can enlighten me, but I would expect that software like this is 99% image processing, and the choice of OS makes little or no difference. I can understand, all thing being equal, using the OS you're more comfortable with... but jesus they make it sound like Linux saved the day here, when that's their only argument.
We always make fun of the retarded M$-funded cost-of-ownership studies. How about posting some stories that show the REAL benefit of OSS in everyday applications?
Re:I use linux... (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:I use linux... (Score:2)
I LOVE OSS, BUT THIS ARTICLE IS TRIPE.
Re:I use linux... (Score:1, Insightful)
Now, I have no doubt that they would have saved a great deal of money with this solution over a Windows based solution, but please. Don't try and take credit for things that you have no business taking credit for.
Re:I use linux... (Score:2)
Re:I use linux... (Score:2)
What idiot moderator.. (Score:1)
Re:I use linux... (Score:4, Insightful)
So indeed, in Windows you pay for layer upon layer upon layer of cruft. Once you are done, it works - but it takes a rocket scientist to get there.
With regard to video capture, in Linux you can do this:
$ cat videodata.raw
and it will give you some sort of raw video frames that you can easily process later. In Windows you first need to learn about 10 layers of software, each totally different, that allow you (in theory) to access the device. DirectX would be your first stop.
Re:I use linux... (Score:1)
Re:I use linux... (Score:4, Informative)
Or you can just leave those parameters as NULL, in which case (e.g. SECURITY_ATTRIBUTES) the call inherits the setting from the current process, just like it says in the MSDN. You do read the MSDN, right?
DirectX would be your first stop.
And your last stop, because RIGHT THERE IN THE DX8.1 SDK is code to do what you want:
It took me about half a day to take this code and write a video capture app which we could hook into our FPGA dev board to demonstrate our product.
Yes, the Windows APIs are bigger and scarier than the equivalent UNIX APIs (where equivalents exist). The wealth of examples and development communities more than makes up for this, IMO.
Jon.
To be fair... (Score:2, Informative)
I'm afraid it's the old rule coming into play here; Some complicated tasks require comp
Re:I use linux... (Score:2)
So for me, yeah, it's easier to grab video with Linux.
-uso.
Re:I use linux... (Score:4, Interesting)
Although I've never tried video programming in Windows, I did try it in Linux. I ended up giving up fairly quickly, because although the individual V4L API calls are documented, there is no documentation stating which calls are necessary to get something to happen, or in what order you have to call the different functions. Getting something working involves a lot of trial and error. So I'm sure for video purposes, Windows would be easier to code.
Anyway, that completely misses the point of the line you quoted. The author chose Linux because he wanted an OS that wouldn't crash, not one that was easy to program for. If OS #1 provides an easy to use but crash prone API, and OS #2 provides a harder to use but stable API, #2 is the better choice.
Oh, and from my personal experience on lots of systems, Windows NT/2000/XP are terribly unstable when doing video capture. Both with consumer and professional grade capture devices.
My TV set (Score:2)
I've done hundreds of hours of video capture in Win2K with nary a glitch. Bad hard drives will screw things up, but that's a bandwidth and timing issue, not an OS issue. Hell, I used to run a capture every single night (Voyager) and surf the net at the same time - running win2k on a 450MHz PII machine.
Re:I use linux... (Score:2)
Unfortuante name choice... (Score:4, Funny)
"...LINServo to capture and rate the video footage and PMSVideo for clients to look at the finished footage..."
I have 6 sisters, PMSVideo is not something I'd like to see. It sounds like a really horrible fetish video.
But then again after reading other details...
"...so far generated about 1.3 terabytes of video footage..."
"...Due to limitations of the Linux firewire drivers, only 896 meg of RAM gets used..."
"...we took out the air-conditioner and added a second alternator..." YIKES!
I can maybe see why it was named as such!
~Z
Re:Unfortuante name choice... (Score:2)
MILLENIUM train (Score:2, Interesting)
aarrh!
Won't Make Much Difference... (Score:3, Interesting)
It's fairly typical of VicRoads to resurface perfectly good roads regularly (every 6-12 months) and the roads that are actually in bad shape get ignored, or made worse... I guess it must have something to do with where the money lives...
Re:Won't Make Much Difference... (Score:2)
Re:Won't Make Much Difference... (Score:2)
But yes, you rattle down the Hume until the Murray River and then it is bliss. I think the sky is even bluer in VIC.
PMS? (Score:3, Funny)
What an unfortunate acronym. Maybe when they get an editor put together they can call it STD Edit.
Re:PMS? (Score:2)
There's already a video editor called VD [virtualdub.org].
pity that they dont actually fix the roads (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:pity that they dont actually fix the roads (Score:2)
Basically, about half the turns that are not labeled should be, and half the turns that are labeled don't need to be. Okay, m
This has nothing to do with Linux ... (Score:1, Insightful)
moronic statement (Score:4, Funny)
I realize that MSWindows has a zillion bugs, but I never knew that its bits could shake loose from going over bumps.
Re:moronic statement (Score:2)
This is to a lesser degree, of course, but having to stop their survey and wait for a "tech guy" to drive out and fix the computer would be a real pain. Having to stop the survey because the OS needs to be rebooted would be a lesser pain, but still a pain. And when did the
scary experience... (Score:5, Funny)
Sounthern Australia border?? I would assume that all that water wouldn't be good for them either.
Re:scary experience... (Score:2, Informative)
Re:scary experience... (Score:5, Funny)
Pioneer 1: So, we have two states left, one in the South and one in the West. Ideas ?
Pioneer 2: South Australia and Western Australia - now for *^%* sake lets hit the pub.
Pioneer 1: I like it. Lets go.
Re:scary experience... (Score:2)
Pioneer 1: Erm...how about North Australia?
Pioneer 2: No, we only reserve creative names for states. It's not a state.
Pioneer 1: Okay, anyway it's beer o'clock now. I'm sure we'll think of a fitting name later on.
Re:scary experience... (Score:2)
Dont forget to wind your watch back 10 years
Re: Linux Hits the Road (Score:1)
Sorry, couldn't resist. I wonder if yearly vehicle registration fees will decrease now? VicRoads charge ~$440 for a light vehicle, and ~500 for a medium vehicle. That's more than one weeks wage for many people.
Maybe if VicRoads switched all their systems and PCs to Linux; vehicle ownership would not be out of reach for so many. I should send them a Tux t-shirt with my next payment
And they can keep them... (Score:3, Funny)
I can back this up.. (Score:3, Funny)
We're so impressed with Linux, we're running one rig at >110 with 2.6.0-test3. We'll save hundreds of thousands of dollars more. It even has 802.11g, as I'm typing this ri--*eerrrrrrrrrr* *sqqqqqueeeeeellll* *BOOM*
*BANG*
*CRASH*
CSIRO did it first... (Score:5, Informative)
See here [csiro.au] for details.
Q.
actually (Score:2)
A pity, though (Score:3, Interesting)
Server slashdotted (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Server slashdotted (Score:2)
And all that thanks to cheap labour using
Some are so addicted that they pay to do their work early.
Linux Saves the Day (Score:2, Funny)
"My experience with Mitsubishis is limited. I have been a Holden driver since 1993 and I have considerable experience driving their vehicles," Smith said. "In any case, I don't think that I woul
The state next door did this already... (Score:5, Informative)
The CSIRO's RoadCrack [csiro.au] system is designed to find cracks in the pavement as small as 1mm wide, at 'highway speeds' of up to 105Km/h (65Mph).
The link doesn't say when this one was built, but it won awards in 1999, and was 'upgraded' in 2001.
Re:RTOS? (Score:1)
Re:RTOS? (Score:1, Funny)
Re:RTOS? (Score:4, Interesting)
Cause they don't need one. The shutters are triggered every metre (or 20 metres) and it works just fine.
Forgive me for asking such a silly question but did you actually read the article?
Re:Map makin'? (Score:1)
Let's map them potholes. 'nuff said.
Heh. I thought you said, "Let's map them open ports" with Linux! Silly me staying up late at night.
Re:Map makin'? (Score:3, Funny)
Re:Go figure (Score:4, Funny)
"My experience with Windows is limited."
Were it not so, he would be able to join the rest of us in saying:
"My experience with Windows is limiting."
Re:Go figure (Score:4, Insightful)
Re:Go figure (Score:3, Insightful)
Are you saying that the OS has no effect on the cost at all?
Re:Go figure (Score:2)
Also, the article distinctly points to the custom software being the cause of increased performance. It was developed under Linux, because that's what the developer knew, not because of cost-benifit analysis.
Re:Go figure (Score:3, Interesting)
I don't usually respond to anonymous cowards but.. (Score:4, Interesting)
He said he had limited, experiance, not no experience. And with bill gates confession that five percent of windows systems crash more than twice a day [osnews.com] the chances of him knowing all two well the habit that MS systems have of failing
and don't tell me that KDE never crashes
Why would a survey device with the job of simply recording data use KDE, or for that matter GNOME, or even X? Somehow I seriously doubt that KDE's crashing effects this thing in the slightest.
Back in the days when I used KDE I saw it crash a number of times (not as frequently as most MS user interfaces I have used), but even if they were running KDE they cirtainly woudn't be stupid enough to have the data monitoring program running on top of it, and so therefore the mission critical application would continue to run perfectly. This is not as much of an option for windows setups when a UI failure or a falure of a non-essential subsystem can take down the entire system.
Re:I don't usually respond to zealots but.. (Score:2)
5% of systems is nothing in the scheme of things. It's easy to put that down to the morons out there that simply run the spyware that comes down to Kazaa.
Why would a survey device with the job of simply recording data use KDE, or for that matter GNOME, or even X? Somehow I seriously doubt that KDE's crashing effects this thing in
Re:What's kph? (Score:2)
Meanwhile kilometers per hour says exactly the same thing. Kilometers (check) (implied: traversed) per hour (check). Kilometers and hours, what more do you want? I think you're being overly nitpicky even for slashdot.
To moderators: This is not a troll, it is the trut (Score:2)
Incidentally, Australian roads already suck, from what I hear all over this story. So even if they find the potholes (potholes, unlike cracks, are easy to find) they probably won't fix them, or they'll go make some more to preserve the conservation of potholes.