Mandrake Announces Turn-Key Clustering Distribution 187
joestar writes "According to their website, Mandrake and partners (Bull, INPG/INRIA...) have launched an 'easy-to-deploy easy-to-use Linux Clustering solution,' that has already been tested on a 40-node cluster. Of course, it's published under the GPL, comes with parallel applications, and is available for download as an ISO. It seems the project is financed by French government. It's great because I've always dreamed of having my own supercomputer at home."
Imagine.. (Score:5, Funny)
Gotcha!
Re:Imagine.. (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Imagine.. VMWare? (Score:1)
Sybill, anyone?
Yeah, what do call a cluster of Mandrake systems? (Score:2)
And yes I'm happy we can finally tell the guys who ask "Can you imagine a cluster of these?" to shut up and build it.
No SCSI (Score:3, Informative)
A fast ethernet network switch
NO SCSI drives in nodes
A PXE bootable network card (intel / 3com)
A 3D accelerated video card for the virtual reality 3D engine
Seems a bit limiting - no SCSI drives?
Re:No SCSI (Score:2)
Re:No SCSI (Score:4, Informative)
Re:No SCSI (Score:2, Insightful)
Re:No SCSI (Score:2)
Re:No SCSI (Score:5, Informative)
Re:No SCSI (Score:3, Insightful)
Re:No SCSI (Score:1, Insightful)
Re:No SCSI (Score:1)
Gigs and gigs of file I/O are going to kill you, as a lot of parallel applications will dump out scratch files to disk. Tell me, is it faster to dump data to a ATA133 or U160 Disk, or gigabit ethernet to a congenested NFS mount?
I can cite examples, such as g98, Amber, Fluent, and other scientific apps you might want to run an a beowulf who tend to dump out check point files.
yes and no (Score:2, Interesting)
no, they're not better off, because where is your swap going to be? or temporary data generated by individual jobs?
i run a 100 node computational cluster. the nodes boot with pxe, then if they are already installed, they simply boot to their local scsi drives. only
i've had more problems with ram and myrinet than the 'moving parts', aka drives.
Re:No SCSI (Score:2, Interesting)
Re:No SCSI (Score:1)
Re:No SCSI (Score:3, Informative)
Re:No SCSI (Score:1)
Cluster? (Score:3, Funny)
OH WAIT! I CAN!
Imagine... (Score:2, Funny)
Phases from the Article (Score:3, Interesting)
1. This one is nromal.
- Phase 1: Develop and release a specialized Linux distribution that contains everything needed to quickly deploy a ready-to-run cluster.
2. I think this means ?????
- Phase 2 (early 2003): Release of specialized administration, control and monitoring tools for the clustering solution, plus added support for Itanium 2 architecture.
3. And finally, PROFIT!!!!!
- Phase 3 (end of 2003): Release of specialized tools and applications for development in parallel environment, final integration and tests, release of the final stable version.
Energy Usage? (Score:5, Insightful)
Re:Energy Usage? (Score:1, Insightful)
what about... (Score:1)
Re:Energy Usage? No Problem! (Score:1)
ReTime drift (Score:1, Offtopic)
Boxes w/o games running on them usually don't gain or loose more than a few seconds per year, in my experience.
Noo....Nooooo....... (Score:3, Funny)
If it was financed by the French government, does this mean that Mandrake is going to become the Renault of the Linux world? Eww...
Re:Noo....Nooooo....... (Score:5, Funny)
Re:Noo....Nooooo....... (Score:1, Funny)
Nope. (Score:1, Funny)
Re:Nope. (Score:4, Funny)
Re:Noo....Nooooo....... (Score:1)
So instead of Le Car we're gonna have Le CD? Le OS?
Re:Noo....Nooooo....... (Score:2)
now I can cluster all my 386/486's (Score:5, Funny)
Re:now I can cluster all my 386/486's (Score:2, Funny)
only imagine the breathtaking view of your full 2d @640x480 at 53Hz refresh!!! almost ready to run clustered doom!!
NOPE! (Score:4, Informative)
Re:NOPE! (Score:2)
Ugh, you caused me to remember purchasing a Pentium Overdrive chip for a Packard Bell desktop many a year ago... of course the CPU was soldered onto the main board, and I had to return the Pentium upgrade...
Preemptive strike (Score:5, Interesting)
If we want to make our inroads we must do so now.
Re:Preemptive strike (Score:2)
Re:Preemptive strike (Score:2)
> and helping them implement it "no good"?
Granted, if you are a Solaris fan, you'll be cheering for Sun (maybe...), but you'll still do a double-take at the news that Sun is out to try and "invent" distributed clustering. Read the CNet article carefully:
CNet may be totally off their rocker (which wouldn't surprise me), but I think it's more likely Sun provided this misinformation, verbatim, in a press kit to CNet. Sun's trying to be the first out the door when they're not; they're offering their service at a premium, saying 'this is the only way you can distribute your data centre'. That's what I call misleading advertisment.
I'm building a CLIC Cluster (Score:5, Interesting)
Just as a weekend project, I was going to use the Beowulf software, but this CLIC software looks quite interesting, considering it's a total package and probably comes with the ease of use of Mandrake, so I'm going to give it a try.
All I have to do is get the PCs out of the shed, make a lot of CAT5 cables, format quite a few hd's with CLIC, and build my own Beo^H^H^HCLIC cluster out of crappy Pentium II's and do something stupid like calculate PI to a googol digits, even though my power bill will probably be insane.
Wish me luck, I'll keep you posted!
Why not LTSP & Mosix? (Score:2)
Wouldn't a LTSP+mosix [lpmo.edu] cluster do the same thing without having to touch the hard drives?
Re:I'm building a CLIC Cluster (Score:5, Funny)
Heh. If anybody calls you a dork, it's cos you earned it!
Re:I'm building a CLIC Cluster (Score:1)
If you document this, let me know the URL.
if one more person... (Score:2, Funny)
"A BEOWULF CLUSTER!! (Score:-1, FUCKING RETARDED)"
Re:if one more person... (Score:3, Funny)
I conclusion, do you really think a good way to have BEOWULF CLUSTERS mentioned less frequently is to talk about BEOWULF CLUSTERS? I doubt it.
Cheers,
BEOWULF CLUSTERS
Re:if one more person... (Score:2, Funny)
Man that thing would SCREAM, baby!
home clusters (Score:2, Informative)
French Govt Eh? (Score:3, Funny)
Re:French Govt Eh? (Score:2)
Alright! (Score:5, Funny)
Take this puppy to school! (Score:1)
I wonder if there's a multi-threaded Folding client......
Re:Take this puppy to school! (Score:2)
Why? Just run one app per processor. I do this on my NT box. Just make sure you configure it right.
Re:Take this puppy to school! (Score:1)
Being who they are, I'm sure the French government has the surrender mode fully worked out.
Bad. Though it does remind me of my favorite French millitary joke:
Q: Why are there so many trees on the Champs Elysees?
A: Because the Germans like maching in the shade.
whoa! the speed the power!! (Score:4, Interesting)
Seriously though. How cool is Mandrake? First to LSB, full GPL'd version of cd avail for download (damn you SuSE!!), lots of freebies, like the Single network firewall and the old Corporate server(i loved this back in the day), their prosuite stomps any other distro (and for $135 without doc's!), oh and mandrake runs on XBox!!
Now a cluster??
My only complaint is they are an RPM-based distro and I like apt-get. Something like the freebsd ports collection would be nice too though, but i just hate those rpm's.
Just so you don't think I'm a linux leech I have bought 3 version of linux inlcuding mandrakes prosuite, i can't donate code but i can donate ca$h.
Re:whoa! the speed the power!! (Score:2, Informative)
The tool is urpmi and the equivalent to debian unstable is cooker.
Other interesting sources is contribs (unsuported contributions) and plf (stuff with legal issues to be official mdk packages).
Dont compare apt-get to rpms. Compare debs to rpms.
Re:whoa! the speed the power!! (Score:1)
Use urpmi, unless you're a debian geek.
i sense a disturbance in the force, a new erra
Re:whoa! the speed the power!! (Score:1)
urpmi is your friend (Score:3, Informative)
From the command line, urpmi will give you similar functionality (mainly deal with the dependencies for you). And even nicer, the GUI for Software Management in MandrakeControlCenter is just beautifull. Really painless software management, as long as you install software from the installation CDs or urpmi-aware repositories. Security updates are just a few clicks away and you get to see the advisories and decide what you want to install and what you don't. When installing from CD's you are prompted to insert the CD's in the order they are needed. You can search for packages (in names, files and descriptions). I NEVER had any problems, never had to manually solve dependencies (with ML 9.0). It works like a charm ...
Gibraltar bootable CD? Diffuse fileservers? (Score:2)
But more immediately;
So how about combininng all the no-fuss PVM setup stuff with the Gibraltar bootbale Debian CD?
OK, maybe not as neat as PXE, but imagine being able to convert the office LAN into a Beowulf cluster every night when people go home.:o)
Xix.
P.S. Anyone notice how many more new ideas are popping up compared to "clone product X" ideas?
Who will really use it? (Score:3, Interesting)
They were commissioned (Score:3, Interesting)
So Mandrake didn't really do this to make more money off it, they're already getting paid for it, we just get a nice new toy to play with.
Re:They were commissioned (Score:2)
This is what should be replied to the usual "if we don't sell software, how do programmers get paid ? " whinning.
Take your pick... (Score:2, Funny)
b) [Some Beowulf joke or another]
Sounds cool as long as....... (Score:1, Troll)
I may be ignorant but, whenever I tried to update anything or install anything, I was told that a dependency was not found. With a cursory exploration, I found that the dependency was there but low and behold everything has been renamed!
MDK is a pain in the a$$!
If they have stopped this practice of renaming files I am unaware as I have moved on to a more standard linux distro.
Re:Sounds cool as long as....... (Score:2)
I can't wait to go back because each and every time I have tried to compile something nifty the process has failed because due to irresolvable dependency issues. This is what originally pushed me over to Gentoo from Mdk8.2, and once again I'm being pushed back.
Mandrake is, like all the "latest and greatest" attempts at being a simple install (e.g., lindows, lycoris, redhat, xandros, etc.) FANTASTIC so long as you never plan on using anything not included in the distro, and never plan on upgrading any software package.
That's fine for an office worker I suppose, but given the choice I'll take Debian or Gentoo any day. At least I know that when I get return to Gentoo when I type configure/make/make install I won't have to start crying!
So how long.. (Score:1)
It would be great to be able to have a bunch of friends bring their Xbox over and cluster them together.
Oh Sure..... (Score:1)
~Evil begets Evil, but Bagels are tasty!
What kind of cluster? (Score:1)
Re:What kind of cluster? (Score:5, Informative)
Right. Netware 6 has kick-ass "clustering" that allows a Server to go down, and a 2nd server to beome your file server. You can stream a video (from FILE), down a server, and after a second, your stream will continue - from the 2nd server.
Most of us call that failover, but Microsoft and Novell are calling it clustering.
Re:What kind of cluster? (Score:2)
Re:What kind of cluster? (Score:2)
To do what? File Serving? SQL Server?
I believe NFS is 'HA', and I believe Postgres SQL would also be HA. There are also Linux-based load balancers available, so if you wanted to do something as simple as have 2 servers with static web pages, the load balancer would NAT those two systems, and direct requests to whatever one had the lowest load. That includes being completely down too :)
One nifty HA application is Email. Take a look at Matt Simersons FreeBSD email toaster [simerson.net] (The Same apps are available on Linux) for a way to setup a HA Email cluster. It describes one system, but add NFS and MySQL replication, and you have HA.
Re:What kind of cluster? (Score:2)
the load balancer would NAT those two systems,
Of course you would need at least two loadbalancers to. Available here.
http://www.linuxvirtualserver.org/
The stuff you can do with these kernel patches cost about $1000 for a hardware solution. And more if you want failover.
obligatory bad joke here (Score:1)
hell, i'll allow a server to go down on me, he he he...
MPI/LAM (Score:3, Interesting)
Re:MPI/LAM (Score:1)
Urpmi parallel (Score:4, Informative)
This tool allow people to deploy RPMS to a group of linux hosts using an intelligent parallel copy.
How does it works:
You create a group of hosts so the server can ask the nodes (using urpmi) to prepare for an update/install of packages.
Each computer tell the server the packages it needs then the server copy in parallel (using ka-tools) the rpms on the nodes (that's very fast even for a hudge number of nodes).After that, nodes update their system using local rpms !
This feature seems to be designed for clusters but should be used by admins !
Another point of comparaison between urpmi & apt-get
Open Source And Government Contributions (Score:5, Interesting)
I have lately started being more and more convinced that one of the key issues to success of open source - in a business sense, will be the fact that it is much easier for government organizations and other similar-type organizations to fund them without being guestioned and having put their moral in doubt. Why? Every single time that Microsoft, Adobe or some other closed source company is looking for government money, the politicians are facing a rather guestion: "In what light will this put us?"
Now, it would be interesting to see some years further and see how this all changes. I am convinced that there will much more public discussion on the subject whether this is discrimative against the non-open source companies. In my opinion it basicly is not, because being open source, it benefits everyone and not just a single company - but still, there's still someone who benefits most.
If I switch to Mandrake... (Score:1)
Or does that require setting up a cluster?
Mandrake club Cluster benifits... (Score:3, Interesting)
I don't know what the hell I would use it for / get out of it, but it would be a nice way to support your favorite distro by donating unused cpu time to MCC (Mandrake Club Cluster)
I've always wanted a super computer (Score:1)
Re:I've always wanted a super computer (Score:1)
Interfering with the Free Market (Score:2, Funny)
Fnord.
XBOX Version (Score:4, Funny)
Bill: What's going on here. Sales of the XBox have risen 500%, but I'm making no money because no one's buying software!!
MS Lackey: It's the French, sir.
Bill: What?! How so?
MS Lackey: Those Mandrake linux people released an ISO image of linux for the XBox, sir, and then they released clustering software. XBox supercomputing clusters are now springing up all over the place.
Bill: Quickly, we must couteract this. Launch a shared source initiative, and I want the records showing everyone who has puchased an XBOX without buying any games for it!
MS Lackey: Right away, sir.
Bill: Oh, and while you're at it, buy France, jail the government, and burn down the Mandrake offices. That'll teach them.
Turn-Key? What's Next? Synergy Clustering? (Score:1)
Bah! Such rubbish!
Anyone agrees with me?
The real point (Score:2, Insightful)
Terrasoft Solutions... Orginality (Score:1)
And no I don't work in anyway for TerraSoft.
Clustering for Dummies, anyone? (Score:2, Interesting)
I've got machines all over the place, and have long fantasized about setting up a cluster for the fun of it. I've read a little about Beowulf and one or two other open source clustering technologies, but have never had the gumption to crack the books and set one up. Mostly, I think, because I'm not sure what I'd do with it when it was ready.
Would anyone care to post a 2-3 paragraph summary of what Joe PC Hobbyist (e.g. someone like me, with many semi-obsolete PCs lying around the house) might be able to do with the CLIC software? Would it only be able to run applications written for CLIC (oh.), or would the cluster behave like one giant, amalgamated Mandrake box (cool!) ?
Re:Clustering for Dummies, anyone? (Score:2, Interesting)
For kernel 2.4.18, openMosix consists of two kernel patches - a kernel patch to actually do the clustering, and a kernel patch for administration. You patch your kernel, change a few settings (all documented on the site), reboot (gasp!), and you're done.
You can get more fancy with net installs, but you don't really need to for a small number of nodes. Anyway, I just used a Fast Ethernet switch - the boxes all came with Ethernet cards, luckily for me.
Mine is a pretty craptacular cluster, but hey, it's pretty cool to have one. The cluster behaves like one powerful computer in the sense that processes on one machine will migrate to another. However, in order to achieve any noticeable affect, the program has to take advantage of multiple CPUs. If you're going to program your own, look into forking, message-passing interface (MPI), and parallel virtual machine (PVM). Sorry, I don't have the addresses for them on hand, I think www.beowulf.org [beowulf.org] links to them.
Energy? (Score:2)
Booyaa (Score:2)
RedHat + OpenMosix rpms... (Score:3, Informative)
You will need:
MOSIX... (Score:1)
I have a small 6-node cluster of P2s running openMosix [openmosix.org]...
You've always dreamed of this? (Score:2)
So uh, get a playstation 2. Or a G4. Ha ha.
You know clustering has been around for a god damned long time, and (low end) PCs have been cheap for a less long but still considerable amount of time. You could have built yourself something decent a couple years ago.
If this is the answer you've been waiting for all this time, I'm not sure I want to know what the question was.
Still in the game (Score:2)
Awesome! Just when I was about to declare Red Hat the winner, Mandrake comes up with a "cluster in a can". Great news.
Re:oooh (Score:2, Funny)
Re:Heh (Score:1)
Which bit of this sentence didn't you understand?
Re:What about Rocks (Score:5, Interesting)
Check it out: Rocksclusters [rocksclusters.org]
Re:What about Rocks (Score:1)
it will be integrated soon
>Easily reinstalled nodes
Also in CLIC, less than 2 min for reinstalling node(s)(1->200 in the same time)
>Pre-installed queue software
Idem, OpenPBS is installed and running
The maui scheduler will be integrated soon also
>brain dead admin tools
Basic parallel tools in CLIC but working fine
Including ka-tools that rox !
>No French Government
CLIC is GPL so it doesn't matter
Re:me too (Score:2)